Sergio Stephano, the Managing Director of Adaptia Design, shares insights on the changing landscape of SEO in light of advancements in AI search tools. Many business owners express concern: if AI can provide answers directly, does SEO remain relevant? The verdict is clear—SEO is more important now than ever.
Shifts in User Behavior
Recent studies highlight significant shifts in how users engage with search results. A report from the Pew Research Center indicated that users exposed to AI-generated summaries clicked on traditional search results only 8% of the time, compared to 15% for those who didn't. Furthermore, a mere 1% of users clicked on links within the AI summary itself. This demonstrates a tangible drop in organic click-through rates, particularly among searches displaying AI Overviews.
Data from Seer Interactive examined over 3,000 informational queries and found a staggering 61% drop in organic traffic from AI-infused searches between mid-2024 and September 2025. Despite this reduction in clicks, the user base for AI tools, as highlighted by Alphabet's CEO Sundar Pichai, has ballooned to over 1 billion monthly active users. Therefore, while rankings are still relevant, they alone do not guarantee traffic anymore.
Understanding AI's Relationship with the Web
AI responses are not concocted out of thin air; they derive from pre-existing content on the web that has been indexed and trusted by search engines. Google's guidelines confirm that the same foundational SEO practices are essential for content to appear in AI summaries. What's altered, however, is the selection process for these source materials.
A study by Ahrefs analyzed 863,000 keyword results and revealed that only 37.9% of URLs cited in AI Overviews were in the top 10 for the same keyword—a drop from approximately 76% in earlier assessments. Similar findings from Semrush indicated that URLs highlighted by ChatGPT frequently ranked at position 21 or lower on related queries. This suggests that content must comprehensively cover a topic rather than just focusing on isolated keywords.
Case Study: The Law Firm Example
A particular law firm approached us, questioning the AI tools' insights about them. Upon review, we found that AI-generated answers referenced several law directories where the firm had presence, but not necessarily the directory in question. Notably, it drew from the firm’s Better Business Bureau (BBB) profile, which lacked reviews or accreditation, impacting the AI's portrayal of them.
Prioritizing the enhancement of their BBB profile emerged as a vital step. Seeking reviews and ensuring that verified case results were indexed in the right places became key strategies for improving their AI visibility.
Best Practices for SEO in the Age of AI
To remain competitive, here are some recommendations:
- Focus on being cited: Structure your key pages to include clear answers at the top, reinforced by solid data, examples, and credible authorship.
- Cover comprehensive questions: Anticipate and address follow-up inquiries from customers while linking related content thoughtfully.
- Maintain a strong technical foundation: When transitioning platforms, ensure redirect mapping and other SEO protections are applied to safeguard traffic.
- Build authority: Cultivate your web presence across reviews, directory profiles, and credible backlinks to strengthen the overall signal about your brand.
- Track meaningful data: Measure how often AI mentions your brand, alongside tracking branded searches and conversion rates, as AI visitors can prove to be more valuable.
The bottom line is that the entities excelling in AI-driven search will not be those chasing every trendy tool. Instead, they will focus on fostering clarity and trustworthiness about their offerings for both users and AI systems alike.
In a rapidly evolving digital landscape, SEO remains a steadfast ally, one that now carries even greater significance as we adapt to AI enhancements.